Saturday, October 24, 2009

Possible Final Project Topic

So after much thought and careful consideration I have a couple of topics to chose from... Let me know which one you would rather read about... I would really enjoy the feedback!
1. Black market organs and payment for these organs.
2. Egg donation and compensation
3. Organ donation and who gets organs when they are avaliable?

Black market organs would be easier, but I'm not one to take the easy route. Egg donation is different because not all companies compensate the same. And organ donation is a bit trickier system because yes they have the organ donor list, but there are controversies on weather such list should be honored if one patients need is more urgent than the patient on the top of the list.
Tell me what you think!!

6 comments:

  1. I found you in a homesick for the eastcoast moment. Right now I'm in South Dakota wishing I was at the ocean. No sense starting a blog with the easy stuff,just jump right in. Good luck.I'll keep checking back.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You've chosen some really in depth topics, Amanda. Personally, I think the organ donation topic the best. This is such a controversial issue that I think it would be fascinating to see what kind of facts and figures you can find on this. We touched a little bit on this subject in my medical law class, and I would love to see what you come up with in your research. Just my opinion :) Good luck!

    ~Hollie

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mandy,

    You have choosen some good topics. I have researched your topics in previous classes and I think that they are all good ones. Yes, the organ donor paper would be a very contiversial one, and you would have to be careful about voicing your opinion without realizing you are. I dont know much about egg donation other then I have ethical thoughts about that LOL, and I can say I dont know anything at all about the black market organ sales. I know this probley doesnt help you much to make up your mind, but those are my thoughts.
    Sherry W.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very interesting topics to choose from. My personal favorite is the black market organ sales. I read some stuff about that and it is some crazy thing that people are doing. Most of it comes from China and the former Soviet Union where you get your new organs. One of the sickest thing is that China has these public executions for people who do some serious crimes. Now when the criminal is killed, they just take the organs, freeze it and sell it. The victim or familly memebers do not sign off any waivers or release forms nor are they compensated for it in any sort of way.

    I don't know if you remember but a couple of years ago, there were exhibits of human bodies in the US. There were two companies that did this. One was called Body Works and the other was called Bodies. I went to the Body Works one and it was a great exhibit. At the end of the exhibit, they give you a form if you want to donate your body when you die for their exhibit. This is the legal way of doing it. The other, while equally great, never offered the form. Guess which one is being questioned about using dead criminals from China?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks everybody so much!! Your thoughts have been so helpful!! I agree the black market is interesting, but I haven't been able to find a lot of hard factual information on it as of yet.. But my search continues!!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello.
    Those are some great topics. Personally I would love to read about egg donation because that is something I have thought about doing in the past. Just never looked to much into it. Anyways I am sure whatever you choose will be great!

    ReplyDelete